6 Columbus Central Park Hotel

Location and staff were excellent. Bathroom decor and amenities, linens and bed comfort were great. Room was quiet, got a good night's sleep.

Room was tiny, like a shoebox. Not even acceptable by NYC standards. Snacks/minibar items took up much of only counter space in room, not needed. Furniture and decor of room was, frankly, ugly. Odd smell in hallway and stairwell, dark dismal vibe.

Good location.

Too few elevators. Drawer under the bed would not stay closed.

Watch out for families with unruly children.

Spaniards in the next room with a constantly crying baby plus a brood of 3 young children. Every morning the young children would run up and down the hallway playing loudly and sceaming at 7am. The parents never came out to corral them. I had to straighten them out one morning and other guests called the front desk. The rooms are dark because they’re blacked out so you can’t see the pigeon scourge. Easy fix is to professionally shoo them away, get rid of the nests and cover the spaces with wire.

The bathtub didn’t drain. This is a pet peeve and a hygiene concern.